Who would you have to replace Fletch ?

[agentgreen]

Richard Money

 

[Green Matt]

Couldn't give you a name. I'd expect Argyle, as a professional football club, to be able to make a good decision based on research and fact-finding rather than throwing random names around. Even Dan McCauley managed this, more than once.

 

[Deacster]

Cotterill would be the man if we could get him. Also like John Ward.

 

[Deacster]

Mike Newell

Seemed a good manager but drifted off the scene after his comments about agents. Not sure where he's been of late?

 

[Womble]

Couldn't give you a name. I'd expect Argyle, as a professional football club, to be able to make a good decision based on research and fact-finding rather than throwing random names around. Even Dan McCauley managed this, more than once.

Exactly. Lets do it propely for once.

 

[tigertony]

I don't think money would be a massive stumbling block for a presently out-of-work manager who was hired until season end initially. Phil Brown ?
I also think there are managers with clubs who would join Argyle based on potential. Similar to Steve Evans move to Rotherham (Steve Evans anyone ?? :shock: )
Overall IF CF went I would say Colin Lee. (I'm surprised Lee hasn't been approached as DoF/CEO) and I would replace Nance with, if feasible, Lee Hodges.

 

[npcchewie]

John Ward would be a good choice, he has a wealth of experience at this level and there would be no compo for him.

 

[The Doctor]

Re. Colin Lee. Why would he join Argyle now when he's currently employed as assistant manager at one of the better teams in League 1 (Notts County)?

 

[The Doctor]

Re. John Ward. His most recent spell in management included a season start with no wins in 8 matches and just 1 win in 23 games stretching back into last season (Colchester United). Not the most convincing evidence that he's what we need!

 

[EyeOpener]

Billy Davies

 

[Tim Chown]

If Fletch was no longer manager, I would also like to see Billy Davies here. Whether he'd work for the wage we'd offer is another question of course.

PAFC remains an excellent opportunity for a good manager to 'do a Sturrock' to (re)build their reputation.

tim

 

[Every Saturday]

Argyle would be a very attractive opportunity to many managers

 

[ely grap]

Hahaha, did someone mention Martin Allen. No way would he leave the team that will win this league by 15 points!

No they wont!

 

[X Isle]

If Fletch was no longer manager, I would also like to see Billy Davies here. Whether he'd work for the wage we'd offer is another question of course.

PAFC remains an excellent opportunity for a good manager to 'do a Sturrock' to (re)build their reputation.

tim

Billy Davies doesn't like Plymouth and I don't like Billy Davies.

One way to guarentee someone 'does a Sturrock'......get a Sturrock.

 

[Deacster]

Having looked through this thread I have to say there are no outstanding candidates. Either too inexperienced or experienced with mixed track records. Maybe the board would need to think outside the box and look at non-league, Scotland and Ireland?