Best player to put on a Argyle shirt - In your life time

[samjones]

Not counting Scott Sinclair as Loanee, it would be Friio.

Oh what we would give to have a player half that good now :facepalm:

 

[Clem]

Paul Mariner followed by Wilf Carter followed by Johnny Williams for me followed by Pat Jones, god that makes me old.

 

[Centre Circle]

I started to follow Argyle in Friio's last season, so for me it's Peter Halmosi. He had it all. Swiftly followed by Elliott Ward, Buzsaky, Ebanks-Blake, Nalis and most of the rest of "that" team. Nalis was a class act.

 

[Nunners84]

For me it has to be either halmosi or friio, akos isn't far behind them mind!

 

[Deacster]

Friooooooooo. With honourable mentions to Steve Castle and underated home growners Wottsy and Trigger.

 

[Lesmin]

For me Norman Piper was the best followed by Billy Rafferty

 

[PAFC95]

Friio!! those two goals in the same minute of extra time versus Gillingham was pure genius.
Scott Sinclair also was a class act for the short period of time he was with us

 

[briangreen]

Paul Mariner was the best player ever to play for Argyle,not just in my time but all time.My grandfather was a supporter since Argyle joined the league in 1920 and saw Black,Leslie,Bowden,Tadman,Carter,Tynan etc-he said that Mariner was the best of them all and 35 England caps would suggest he wasn't wrong.

Agree with all that

Rafferty & Mccauley equal silver medal

 

[JonB]

Geoff Crudgington.

Had everything that's missing in today's footballing cohort.

 

[justanotherfan]

Ernie Machin

 

[jonc3725]

70's Rafferty, Mariner
80's Tynan, Hodges
90's Castle, McCall
00's Frio, Evans
since 08 None :facepalm:

Oh just to have one of the above in the team now!

 

[StroudGreen]

Often overlooked, only played 40 odd games before following Malcolm Allison to Man City, but Barry Silkman was for me easily the best player I have seen in an Argyle shirt.

Now a successful high profile football agent!

 

[Connor Clarke]

Peter Halmosi for me.

 

[Every Saturday]

Best - Mariner, Rafferty, Tommy, McCall

Most committed to the Argyle cause - Hodgie and Wotts

Best engine - Chuck Norris

Who would I choose to put in the Argyle team now? - Jock Morrison

 

[Trapdoor]

Machin

Rafferty

Alecksic

Willmott