Next season… you have a choice of Jephcott OR May being at the club.
Which one would you pick?
Phrasing your question differently…
… what if Argyle were offered a 22 year old striker with 30 goals from 100ish games not including penalties, for free?
We’d think it was a gift from god!
Fans always underrate their own strikers and overrate others. There’s a mythology about 20 goal a season strikers, but when you have someone who gets there or close, that still means they’re not scoring from open play in 75% of games and often looking quite ordinary.
So sometimes they aren’t as appreciated as they should (see many Argyle fans’ opinions of Jephcott, Reuben Reid or Freddie Ladapo).
I haven’t seen much of May but Jephcott’s youth suggests he’s much the better bet, and I don’t think May is the type of striker we need.