I've been watching Argyle since the mid-80s and the highs and lows for me...
1984 FA Cup Quarter Final at home to Derby (won the reply)
1984 FA Cup Semi Final at Villa Park
Like a previous poster, I experienced all these...
Promotion 1985/86
Relegation 1991/92
Relegation 1994/95
Promotion 1995/96 *Wembley Play Off Final
Relegation 1997/98
Promotion 2001/02
Promotion 2003/04
Relegation 2009/10
Relegation 2010/11
The second trip to Wembley was a huge anticlimax too!!
The highlight for me as a kid was the FA Cup Semi Final in 84, but the most enjoyable and exciting time as an Argyle fan were the Championship days under Ian Holloway where we dared to toy with the thought of making the Play Offs and played some great football with the likes of Halmosi, Buzsaky, Ebanks-Blake, Gosling, Timar, Norris etc. Obviously, the then board got cold feet, sold off the crown jewels and the rest is history... but for a brief moment, we were at least dreaming of the Premier League!!