Rate the Ref v Peterborough (Carabao Cup) - Alan Young

[PL2 3DQ]

Your thoughts, praise or criticism and marks out of 10 for tonight's referee Alan Young.

 

[Cobi Budge]

Every throw in and every corner was a lottery. I don’t think I’ve ever seen Schumacher so animated toward the officials.

 

[Kevb77]

Appalling. Their 36 hauled down Whitaker, nothing. Then hauled down Ennis, nothing. Then shoved over jephcott, not even a talking to. Has a quiet word with their 22 for nearly slicing Galloway in 2. Wilson has a little tug on their guy, yellow card. Whitaker and Hardie, if not penalties then corners at least. Petty, pedantic and couple with a pair of dimwit linos, possibly the worst I've seen for some time, come back Brett, all is forgiven!

 

[Kevb77]

Every throw in and every corner was a lottery. I don’t think I’ve ever seen Schumacher so animated toward the officials.

Mayflower lino was a joke! Only marginally better than Lindy thou!

 

[Green Painter]

Prima Donna who wanted to be the star of the show. Got a decision completely wrong on the touchline in front of me and booked then Azaz next to nothing in the way of dissent. Please don't come back ref. Can't blame him for the defeat though.

 

[bigalf]

Reminded me of Paul Durkin in his pomp. 'Look at me, Look at me, I'm a referee and I am in charge

 

[LeonTheGreen]

Crap. Pedantic and patronising, could tell from the players reactions whilst attempting to talk with him.

 

[Greenrod]

This referee is probably the worst I’ve seen at Home Park in 60 years along with the Lyndhurst Lino.

 

[Green Painter]

This referee is probably the worst I’ve seen at Home Park in 60 years along with the Lyndhurst Lino.

At least you had a lino over your side, don't think ours turned up!

 

[Stuart Bloye]

Someone gave him a ten! Really, he was awful. The worst set of officials I have seen in many a year.

 

[Tony Flags]

Hard to rate the ref. The linesmen were so amazingly poor it was guesswork for the ref for anything out of direct site.

 

[IJN]

We were in between the two dugouts and both sets of coaches were eventually laughing at them.

I gave him 1.

 

[unhinched]

very poor. but were we fortunate to not concede a penalty when endacott took a risk defending in the box ? anyone get a better view ?

 

[bigalf]

very poor. but were we fortunate to not concede a penalty when endacott took a risk defending in the box ? anyone get a better view ?

I agree and thought that was a penalty as well. Fortunately, the total incompetence of Mr Young got us off the hook

 

[santos73]

Definite penalty but the ref probably wanted to even his decisions up!