Just watched the re-run of the penalty. The ref had a good view of the incident so he was in a good position to make the decision. He did not appear to get any help from the lino on advice, it was his shout. The number 9 was in possession of the ball and running towards goal in our penalty area. Edwards is on his right side, keeping pace with him and closing him down. All of a sudden the No 9 changes direction moving to his right onto Edwards path. Edwards does not change direction. At the same time as his change of direction the No 9 raises his right arm high into the air in an attempt to shove Edwards. It is only at that moment does Edwards raise his left arm to protect himself. He then falls over like a sack of King Edwards spuds. I did not see the incident clearly like the ref did on Saturday, and at the time thought it was a penalty but no red card. Now I have the ref's view it is clear no red card, no penalty. It was a free kick to Argyle for the foul on Edwards, and a booking for the No 9 for the foul and the simulated falling over. Must be overturned on appeal. I am sick of this behaviour in the professional game. It was so refreshing to watch the youth team the other night in the FA cup. No fouling, no falling over, blood and guts football, and the joy on those lads faces to win the game.