Where you sit, or indeed rebelliously stand at Home Park is a matter of personal choice and I believe as Argyle fans we have plenty of choice.
Currently, I choose to sit in the Lower Mayflower and transferred our season tickets from the Lyndhurst to the Lower Mayflower soon after the renovated old stand was re-opened. We do not regret it. The lines of sight are great and being close to the dugouts, players and backroom staff, adds another dimension to each match day. We feel we are much closer to all of the action.
Yes, sometimes it rains, but we are prepared for this. The club also recognise that we may get wet and this is reflected in the price. For us the Lower Mayflower provides great value for money and a great match day experience but I can understand why it is not for everyone.
If I had more money I might consider becomong a Pioneer, or if I wanted a more nostalgic experience and didn't mind the legroom, I might relocate to the Upper Mayflower (yes, I have sat up there since the redevelopment and yes I know some who still love it up there). However, if the Mayflower experiences are not to your liking, then the horseshoe provides plenty of further choice. In the recent past I have rebelliously stood and sung myself hoarse in block 4 and I have been very opinionated and loud in block 12. I am sure that other parts of the Devonport and Lyndhurst provide their own unique experiences.
Surely there is a part of the ground that feels like home for every one of us and therefore I am a little confused why some 'supporters' choose to fuss about the Mayflower experience when what they appear to crave for is found elsewhere at Home Park.