-
Welcome to PASOTI. Sponsored by Lang & Potter
Rate The Ref v Charlton - John Brooks
- Thread starter PL2 3DQ
- Start date
Too whistle happy for me, and seemed to be making it up as he went along. Thankfully, he was poor for both sides. 4/10
Missed a lot and refused to censure their 14 despite dives, obstructing Luke etc. Man up ref 4/10
5 from me.
Could have scored more for 'general performance' but he can't book Miller because 6 of their players surround him and say he should!
We never hassled the ref, so their dives, simulation, pulls and 'tricks' went unbooked. :facepalm:
Could have scored more for 'general performance' but he can't book Miller because 6 of their players surround him and say he should!
We never hassled the ref, so their dives, simulation, pulls and 'tricks' went unbooked. :facepalm:
Decent performance, let the game flow and picked up all the important fouls. Only negative was not booking Fosu for a blatant dive.
- Oct 31, 2010
- 24,342
- 1
- 10,616
IJN":2mw1lt76 said:
One incident of playing advantage was strange. He gave advantage to Charlton and after at least three of their players had touched the ball he pulled it back and gave Charlton a free-kick!
He's in his second season as a ref after being a linesman in the Premier League.
The linesman on the Lyndhurst side, who is a regular at Home Park, didn't help him much.
justanotherfan
🏆 Callum Wright 23/24
✅ Evergreen
Jade Berrow 23/24
🎫 S.T. Donor 🎫
🍌 Bomber Harris.
🚑 Steve Hooper
✨Pasoti Donor✨
🌟Sparksy Mural🌟
PL2 3DQ":2mt5glog said:
Both of these, very strange interpretation, for me it should be advantage given, not taken play on.
PL2 3DQ":2gq7o2vz said:
One incident of playing advantage was strange. He gave advantage to Charlton and after at least three of their players had touched the ball he pulled it back and gave Charlton a free-kick!
[/quote]
There is nothing wrong with the sound of that. Officials are now encouraged to go back and award the free kick if advantage doesn't play out.
Lundan Cabbie":29rfpjfa said:
Play went on for at least 10 seconds which is a long time in football and there were several passes before it was given away. This is football, not rugby.
Lundan Cabbie":13gdv6nt said:
There is nothing wrong with the sound of that. Officials are now encouraged to go back and award the free kick if advantage doesn't play out.[/quote]
Three professional footballers get the ball and fail to advance? So it goes back to a freekick? Stupid rule tbh. Either give a freekick or one period of advantage.
All these 'rules' and messing with things to 'improve' the game are completely overwhelmed by the ref's inability to give straightforward decisions on dives , fouls and cheating.
4 from me. I thought he nearly lost control at one point.
3 things stick in my mind which in my eyes were totally wrong
Miller getting booked when it wasnt even a foul
Their man diving in the second half in our area and he didnt even book him
He miised a load of tackles from behind from both sides.
Not his best day for sure
3 things stick in my mind which in my eyes were totally wrong
Miller getting booked when it wasnt even a foul
Their man diving in the second half in our area and he didnt even book him
He miised a load of tackles from behind from both sides.
Not his best day for sure